Motions to Dismiss Filed in Two Home Seller Cases (Gibson and Umpa)

Louisiana REALTORS® • February 27, 2024

An Update from Katie Johnson, NAR Chief Legal Officer and Chief Member Experience Officer

I'm writing to share a brief litigation update but first let me acknowledge that we understand that these are challenging times for our members and the industry, and we appreciate all the feedback and support as we navigate these challenges toward a positive outcome for property owners and the real estate profession. 


Yesterday, we filed motions to dismiss in two of the copycat home seller class action cases, the Gibson case and the Umpa case, both of which are pending before Judge Stephen Bough in federal court in the Western District of Missouri. 


As you may recall, these two copycat lawsuits were filed late last year, shortly following the Burnett verdict. As in the Burnett case, the plaintiffs in Gibson and Umpa claim that NAR and corporate defendants conspired to force home sellers to pay buyer broker commissions. Both cases are among those the Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation (JPML) will consider centralizing at a hearing scheduled for next month.


NAR's motions raise issues relating to the specific allegations in these national cases that are in addition to those decided by the court in the Burnett case, which is a Missouri-only case. We believe that the cases should be dismissed because listing brokers or buyers, not sellers, compensate buyer brokers and because offers of compensation are authorized by state real estate laws. MLS rules do not require any particular amount of compensation (zero is allowed in some MLSs), and the MLS can be easily avoided by sellers who prefer to avoid any MLS rules.


Other defendants filed motions arguing for additional grounds for dismissal. The plaintiffs will have an opportunity to respond to these motions before the court rules on them.



We will continue to keep you informed about legal milestones. As always, please feel free to reach out to me or my team with any questions.

When is the best time to move in Louisiana

A Louisiana Homeowner's Guide to Deciding When to Buy, Sell, or Move

By Louisiana REALTORS® • July 2, 2026
Thinking about buying, selling, or moving in Louisiana? Explore key factors that can help you decide when the time is right.

Consumer Guide Update: Defining Home Buying Needs vs. Wants

By Louisiana REALTORS® • July 1, 2026
It’s not unusual for people to enter the homebuying process with a priority list that needs to be whittled down once they see what’s on the market. NAR’s latest consumer guide, “Defining Home Buying Needs vs. Wants,” is a decision-making tool that can help. It’s a simple checklist to help home buyers identify their needs, wants and deal-breakers. Using the form, or something like it, will help buyers remember what’s most important to them as they view and compare homes. There’s even a fillable PDF available for download. As a reminder, all guides in this series are available for download—in both English and Spanish—on facts.realtor . Please allow up to two weeks for the Spanish version of the latest resource to be translated and uploaded. For ease of reference, below is a list of the most recent guides: NEW: Defining Home Buying Needs vs. Wants NEW: 10 Tips For Unpacking Smartly After A Move UPDATED: Multiple Listing Services Overcoming Roadblocks to a Sale or Purchase How Solar Impacts a Real Estate Transaction Thank you for your continued engagement with the “Consumer Guide” series and for sharing the resources with prospective clients to ensure they have the information they need to find success in their home buying or selling journey. Remember that these guides are for informational purposes only and are not meant to enact or change any existing NAR policy. Check out the next consumer guide for sellers on how to ease the transition for the new owners.

Consumer Guide Update: 10 Tips for Unpacking

By Louisiana REALTORS® • June 18, 2026
NAR’s latest consumer guide, “10 Tips for Unpacking Smartly After a Move,” was developed to help ease the burden buyers may feel when surrounded by boxes. For your clients on the cusp of a move, the guide suggests establishing a priority unpacking order, wiping down each room before unpacking, discarding boxes quickly, having garbage and donation bags at the ready, and more. Share the new guide along with the companion guide “10 Tips for Packing Smartly for a Move.” As a reminder, all guides in this series are available for download—in both English and Spanish—on facts.realtor . Please allow up to two weeks for the Spanish version of the latest resource to be translated and uploaded. For ease of reference, below is a list of the most recent guides: NEW: 10 Tips For Unpacking Smartly After A Move UPDATED : Multiple Listing Services Overcoming Roadblocks to a Sale or Purchase How Solar Impacts a Real Estate Transaction Navigating Interest Rate Shifts Thank you for your continued engagement with the “Consumer Guide” series and for sharing the resources with prospective clients to ensure they have the information they need to find success in their home buying or selling journey. Remember that these guides are for informational purposes only and are not meant to enact or change any existing NAR policy. Check out the next consumer guide on identifying homebuying wants vs. needs.
Show More